Breaking Down the Basics: Understanding Family Law

Introduction to Family Law

Family law is the area of law that governs legal matters and disputes related to family relationships. It covers a wide range of topics including marriage, divorce, child custody, child support, adoption, domestic violence, and more.

Family law attorneys and judges play an important role in helping families navigate these complex legal issues. They provide legal advice, represent clients in court, negotiate settlements, draft legal documents like prenuptial agreements, and make rulings that significantly impact people’s lives.

Some of the most common legal issues that fall under family law include:

Divorce – The legal process of dissolving a marriage. This involves issues like asset division, spousal support, and child custody.
Child Custody – Determining which parent(s) a child lives with and the visitation rights of the non-custodial parent. Courts consider the child’s best interests.
Child Support – Requiring non-custodial parents to financially support their children. Child support amounts are determined by factors like income and custody arrangements.
Adoption – The legal process where parental rights and responsibilities are transferred to adoptive parents. This permanently severs rights of the child’s biological parents.
Prenuptial Agreements – Legal contracts signed before marriage to determine asset division in case of divorce. They lay out financial obligations and protect assets in case of separation.
Domestic Violence – When family members commit violence or abuse against one another. Restraining orders and other protections may be issued.

Family law guides decisions made during major life events like marriage, divorce, and childrearing. The court system and family law attorneys help navigate the complex legal issues involved.

Getting a Divorce

Divorce legally ends a marriage and divides assets and debts between spouses. The requirements and process vary by state, but generally have some common elements.

Requirements for Filing

In most states, one spouse must meet residency requirements before filing for divorce. This usually means living in the state for 6 months to 1 year prior to filing. The couple must also have grounds for divorce, which can include:

Irreconcilable differences
Adultery
Cruelty
Abandonment
Imprisonment

Not all states require spouses to allege fault-based grounds for divorce. Many accept no-fault divorces based on irreconcilable differences or living separately for a period of time.

Divorce Procedures and Timelines

The spouse filing for divorce completes forms outlining information about the marriage, proposed arrangements for children and assets, and the grounds for divorce. This starts the timeline for the divorce process, which may include:

Serving the petition to the other spouse
Waiting periods before the divorce is finalized (anywhere from 30-90 days)
Filing paperwork for temporary orders regarding child custody, support, alimony
Negotiating the division of assets and debts
Potentially going through mediation or a trial if agreements cannot be reached

The entire process can take anywhere from 3 months to over a year depending on the complexity of the divorce and whether it is contested.

Contested vs. Uncontested

An uncontested divorce is one where the spouses agree on all terms of the divorce. This is generally faster and simpler than a contested divorce.

A contested divorce is where spouses do not agree and go through litigation to resolve issues like:

Child custody and support arrangements
Division of assets and debts
Alimony

Contested divorces require more lawyers and court involvement, increasing costs and time. Most states require divorcing couples to attempt mediation first before going to trial.

Dividing Assets and Debts

The division of marital property and debts depends on whether a couple lives in a community property or equitable distribution state.

In community property states, assets acquired during the marriage are split 50/50. Equitable distribution states divide assets equitably (not necessarily equally) based on factors like income, needs, and childcare responsibilities.

Some assets may be considered separate property, like inheritances, gifts, premarital assets, and assets acquired after separation. Separate property stays with the owning spouse.

Debts accrued during marriage are generally divided equally. Courts may assign certain debts to one spouse, like student loans or credit cards in one spouse’s name.

Child Custody

Child custody refers to the legal and physical guardianship arrangements for children when parents separate or divorce. There are two main types of custody:

Legal Custody

Legal custody determines which parent has the legal authority to make important decisions about the child’s health, education, and welfare. If one parent has sole legal custody, they have the exclusive right to make these decisions without input from the other parent. Joint legal custody means that both parents share the decision-making responsibilities.

Physical Custody

Physical custody establishes where the child lives and which parent is responsible for day-to-day care. Sole physical custody grants one parent primary residence and control of the child. Joint physical custody means the child lives with each parent for significant periods of time.

When determining custody, courts consider factors like the child’s relationship with each parent, the parents’ ability to communicate and cooperate, and stability. The court aims to establish custody that serves the child’s best interests. Unless one parent is deemed unfit, courts favor joint legal custody so both maintain decision-making authority.

Custody orders can be modified if circumstances change substantially. For example, if a parent with sole custody relocates far away. However, courts won’t modify orders without evidence that the changes positively impact the child. Modification requires filing a petition and going through the custody determination process again.

Child Support

Child support is financial assistance paid by one parent to the other parent to help cover the costs of raising a child when the parents live separately. The purpose of child support is to ensure the child’s basic needs are met and to maintain their standard of living.

How Child Support is Calculated

The amount of child support is determined by a mathematical formula that factors in both parents’ incomes and the amount of time the child spends with each parent. The basic calculation is:

Determine the gross income of both parents
Add the parents’ incomes together
Look up the combined income amount on the child support guidelines table for the state
This provides a percentage of income that should go to child support
Apply the percentage to the combined income to get the total child support amount
Prorate the amount based on each parent’s income percentage

This provides a base amount of child support. The court may adjust this amount based on factors like healthcare expenses, childcare costs, and additional needs of the child.

Enforcing and Modifying Child Support Orders

Child support orders are legally enforceable. If the paying parent falls behind on payments, the receiving parent can pursue enforcement remedies through the court like wage garnishment. Modification of the child support amount is possible if there are substantial changes in circumstances like income fluctuations or changes in parenting time. Most states require showing a +/- 15-20% change in the paying parent’s income to modify the order.

Special Circumstances

There are some special circumstances that affect child support:

For 50/50 shared custody, some states decrease child support obligations since both parents have equal time.
If the paying parent is unemployed or facing reduced income, they can request the court to lower payments temporarily. However, job loss cannot be voluntary and they must show efforts to find work.
Cost of living increases and other child expenses like private school tuition may be factored in to increase child support.
If the child has extraordinary medical needs or disabilities, the parents may agree to a higher level of support.
For high income parents, child support may exceed basic needs and align more with the child’s lifestyle. But there are limits to how much courts will award.

Overall, the court has broad discretion to set appropriate child support based on the child’s best interests and individual family circumstances. The goal is to ensure financial stability for the child.

Alimony/Spousal Support

Alimony, also known as spousal support, is financial support paid by one spouse to the other after a divorce. There are several factors courts consider when determining alimony:

Determining Need for Alimony

Income disparity – If there is a significant difference between the incomes of the spouses, the higher earner may be ordered to pay alimony. This aims to balance the standard of living after divorce.
Ability to be self-supporting – Courts examine whether the spouse seeking alimony has the ability to be self-supporting through employment. If not, alimony may be awarded.
Length of marriage – Alimony is more likely in long-term marriages where a spouse may have lost career opportunities.
Health and age – Poor health or advanced age may impair a spouse’s ability to work and be grounds for alimony.

Types of Alimony

There are several types of alimony:

Temporary alimony – Short-term support paid during a divorce proceeding.
Rehabilitative alimony – Time-limited alimony to help a spouse become self-supporting through education or training.
Permanent alimony – Indefinite alimony until remarriage or death of the recipient. Awarded in long marriages.
Reimbursement alimony – Compensates a spouse for supporting the other spouse’s education or career during marriage.

Length of Alimony

Alimony duration depends on the purpose and type:

Temporary alimony lasts during the divorce process.
Rehabilitative alimony typically lasts 1-5 years.
Permanent alimony can last indefinitely. Some states place limits such as half the length of the marriage.
Reimbursement alimony may be lump-sum or short-term payments.

Modifying Alimony Orders

Alimony orders can be modified if there is a substantial change in circumstances, such as job loss, retirement, or illness. The party seeking modification must file a motion with the court.

Property Division

One of the most complex areas of divorce is deciding how to divide marital property. There are two main approaches courts can take:

Equitable vs. Equal Division

Equal division means each spouse gets exactly 50% of the marital property. This is the default in community property states.
Equitable division considers what is fair, given the circumstances of the marriage. This is the approach in common law states. Courts have broad discretion to divide assets equitably.

Marital vs. Separate Property

Marital property includes assets acquired during the marriage. This is subject to division.
Separate property is what spouses owned before marriage or received by gift or inheritance during. Separate property is not divided, unless commingled.

Dividing Specific Assets

The court can award any assets to either spouse, regardless of who holds title. Here’s how some common assets may be divided:

Real estate – The marital home is often sold and proceeds split. One spouse may keep the home with other assets going to the other spouse.
Financial assets – Retirement accounts and investments are divided based on value. The court can award a percentage to each spouse.
Personal property – Furniture, jewelry, and collectibles may be divided item by item or in groups.
Debts – Marital debts are typically divided equally. The court may order one spouse to assume more debt in lieu of other assets.

The goal is a balanced division that serves the needs of both spouses. Courts consider factors like income, age, and custody arrangements. With complex assets, hiring a forensic accountant can help identify and value all marital property to be divided.

Prenuptial Agreements

A prenuptial agreement, often referred to as a prenup, is a contract entered into by a couple before they are married. A prenup details how assets and debts will be divided if the marriage ends in divorce or death.

Purpose of Prenups

There are several key reasons why a couple may want a prenup:

Protect assets they owned before marriage. Without a prenup, assets acquired before marriage are generally considered marital property. A prenup allows people to keep premarital assets separate.
Avoid fights over money if they divorce. A prenup makes it clear who gets what, avoiding prolonged legal battles.
Protect inheritances or gifts. Inheritances and gifts can remain separate property with a prenup.
Set expectations for spousal support. A prenup can waive the right to alimony or set limits on amount/duration.
Protect children from prior relationships. Custody and support of children from previous relationships can be addressed.
Clarify financial rights and obligations during marriage. A prenup can specify who pays which bills, how income is handled, etc.

What Prenups Can and Cannot Address

Prenups are flexible and can address major assets like real estate, businesses, retirement accounts, vehicles, investments, and more. They can also cover personal property, debts, and other financial obligations.

However, prenups cannot address child custody arrangements, as the court decides custody based on the child’s best interests. Prenups also cannot limit child support payments, which are determined by state guidelines.

Enforceability Issues

For a prenup to be enforceable, certain requirements must be met:

There must be full financial disclosure by both parties. Assets, debts, income, and expenses must be revealed.
Each person should retain their own lawyer to review the agreement. This helps ensure proper legal advice.
The agreement cannot be unconscionable or excessively favor one spouse. Courts may refuse to enforce unfair terms.
There must be ample time to review the agreement before signing. Signing under duress close to the wedding could make a prenup unenforceable.
The agreement must be entered into voluntarily. Forced or coerced prenups can be challenged.

As long as the prenup is signed properly with legal counsel, courts typically will uphold the contract.

Process of Creating a Prenup

Here is a general overview of the prenup process:

Hire experienced lawyers. Each spouse should have their own attorney.
Make complete financial disclosures. Tax returns, bank statements, debts, assets, etc. must be revealed.
Draft agreement with lawyers. The lawyers negotiate and draft terms addressing property division, spousal support, etc.
Review carefully. Each spouse should take time to review before signing, at least 30 days in advance of wedding.
Sign with witnesses and notarize. Signing must be voluntary with a notary present.
Store original copies safely. Each spouse keeps an original copy.

With proper precautions, a thoughtfully crafted prenup can provide clarity and avoid future conflict if a marriage ends. Though not romantic, a prenup is an important way to protect assets and set expectations.

Adoption

Adoption is the legal process through which a child becomes a permanent part of a new family. There are several different types of adoption, qualifications to adopt, and steps in the adoption process.

Types of Adoption

Domestic infant adoption – Adopting a newborn or infant within the U.S.
Foster care adoption – Adopting a child who is in foster care within the U.S.
International adoption – Adopting a child from another country.
Kinship adoption – Adopting a child who is related to the adoptive parents.
Adult adoption – Adopting an adult.

Qualifications to Adopt

The qualifications to adopt vary by state and type of adoption, but some general requirements include:

Being over 18 years old. Married couples and single people can adopt.
Having a stable income and financial security.
Passing background checks and home studies.
Being mentally and physically fit to raise a child.
Going through training and classes.
Being open to adopting the types of children who need homes.

Adoption Process and Timeline

The adoption process involves several steps and can take 6 months to several years depending on the situation. Key steps include:

Choosing a type of adoption and agency.
Submitting an application.
Undergoing home studies.
Being matched with a birth mother or child.
Finalizing legal documents and paperwork.
Going through a transition period.
Finalizing the adoption in court.

Open vs Closed Adoptions

In open adoptions, there is contact between the birth parents and adoptive family. In closed adoptions there is no contact. Open adoptions are becoming more common, allowing adopted children to connect with their biological family.

Surrogacy

Surrogacy is an arrangement where a woman carries and gives birth to a child for another person or couple. There are two main types of surrogacy:

Traditional vs Gestational Surrogacy

Traditional surrogacy – The surrogate mother provides her own egg, which is fertilized via artificial insemination using the intended father’s sperm. She carries the pregnancy and gives birth to a child that is genetically related to her.
Gestational surrogacy – The surrogate mother carries the pregnancy but she does not provide the egg. The egg is provided by the intended mother or an egg donor, fertilized via IVF using sperm from the intended father or a donor. The surrogate has no genetic relation to the child.

Gestational surrogacy has become more common in recent years as IVF technology has advanced. Some intended parents prefer gestational surrogacy because it avoids any potential issues regarding the surrogate mother’s parental rights.

Surrogacy Laws by State

Surrogacy laws vary widely by state. Some states, like California, are very permissive towards commercial surrogacy. Others only allow altruistic surrogacy with few or no payments beyond medical expenses. Some states have no laws regulating surrogacy at all. Surrogacy contracts can be complex depending on the state.

It’s important for intended parents and surrogates to research the laws in their state. In some states, surrogacy contracts are not enforceable. Parentage may be determined based on genetics or birth, regardless of any contract.

Surrogacy Contracts and Procedures

Surrogacy arrangements involve extensive contracts detailing all aspects of the process. Contracts typically address things like:

Payment and expense reimbursement for the surrogate
Medical care and procedures
Lifestyle considerations (diet, activities, etc) during the pregnancy
Custody of the child after birth
Situations like miscarriage or multiples

The contract provides clear expectations for all parties involved. Surrogates undergo medical and psychological screening. Legal counsel is strongly advised to protect all parties’ interests.

Once a surrogate is matched with intended parents, the medical process begins. For gestational surrogacy, doctors harvest eggs from the intended mother or donor, and fertilize them via IVF with sperm from the intended father or donor. One or more embryos are then transferred into the surrogate’s uterus.

Using Egg/Sperm Donors

Egg and sperm donors may be used in surrogacy for various reasons, like:

Intended parent(s) are unable to provide viable eggs or sperm
Intended parents are a same-sex couple
To avoid passing on genetic disorders
To maximize chances of pregnancy success

Donor selection involves consideration of desired traits, medical history, etc. Legal consult is advised to understand rights and obligations. The surrogate would not be genetically related to a child conceived using donor egg/sperm.

Surrogacy can provide an alternative means to have a child when pregnancy is medically impossible, unsafe, or undesirable. But it involves significant legal, ethical, emotional, and financial complexity for all parties. Thorough consideration and preparation is crucial before pursuing surrogacy.

Mediation and Dispute Resolution

Mediation can be a less adversarial option for resolving family law disputes compared to litigation. Here are some key things to know about mediation in family law cases:

Benefits of Mediation

More control over the outcome – parties craft their own agreement rather than having a ruling imposed.
Typically less expensive than litigation since there are no court fees and less attorney time.
Usually quicker than court cases which can drag on. Mediations tend to be scheduled promptly.
Improved communication and preservation of relationships – mediation takes a problem-solving approach.
Flexible and informal – parties can get creative with solutions a court may not order.
Confidential process – nothing said in mediation can be used later in court.

Mediator Qualifications

There are no universal requirements to be a family law mediator, but legitimate mediators often have:

Legal training and knowledge of family law. Many are attorneys.
Mediation skills training of at least 40 hours. Some have hundreds of hours.
Background in mental health fields like psychology which aids in resolving emotional issues.
Experience mediating divorce, custody, and other family disputes. Look for a seasoned professional.

Mediation Process

Begins with an introduction explaining mediation procedures and ground rules. Parties sign an agreement to mediate.
Each person provides their perspective. The mediator helps identify issues to be resolved.
Private caucuses are held so each party can speak freely to the mediator. These are confidential.
The mediator facilitates negotiation and proposes options to help the parties reach agreement.
If an agreement is reached, it can be drafted and signed. A written agreement makes the mediation binding.
For divorce and custody, a mediated agreement can be submitted to a court.

Binding vs Nonbinding

Mediated settlements can be either binding or nonbinding:

Binding means the agreement is enforceable in court. Breaching a binding agreement could lead to legal penalties.
Nonbinding agreements rely on good faith of the parties, but have less legal enforceability if violated.

Many mediators only conduct binding mediations to maximize the likelihood of compliance. But some disputes initially use nonbinding sessions to explore options before a final binding agreement.

Disclaimer: The information provided on this blog is for general informational purposes only. All information on the site is provided in good faith, however, we make no representation or warranty of any kind, express or implied, regarding the accuracy, adequacy, validity, reliability, availability, or completeness of any information on the site. Under no circumstance shall LegalGo have any liability to you for any loss or damage of any kind incurred as a result of the use of the site or reliance on any information provided on the site. Your use of the site and your reliance on any information on the site is solely at your own risk. This blog does not constitute legal advice and should not be used as a substitute for legal counsel from a licensed attorney.